°ò·þ«H¥õ§Ûŧ¦Ó¨Óªº¨£¤£±o¤Hªº¯u¬Û
°ò·þ«H¥õ§Ûŧ¦Ó¨Óªº¨£¤£±o¤Hªº¯u¬Û
§@ªÌ: ¤p©¨
Pagan Origins of the Christ Myth¡@By John G. Jackson (Originally published in 1941)°ò·þ¯«¸Üªº²§±Ð°_·½©³²Ó
½Ðª`·N,¦è¤è¾Ç¬É±q¢°¢·¥@¬ö±Ð·|¥´À£©v±Ðµô§P®É¡A´N¶}©l°l¬d³o¨ÇµL®¢ªº§Ûŧ¥j¥N²§±Ð«ä·Q¦Ó«÷´ê¦Ó¦¨ªº°ò·þ±Ðªº©Ò¦³±¬Û¡A±Ð·|¾ú¸g¿N®Ñ©M±þ¤H³£¨SÀ£¤U¼Ú¬w¦U°ê¤¤¥j¥@¬ö¾ÇªÌªº²M¬d,¦Ûªk°êªºC DupuisµÛ®Ñ¥H«á¡A²×ºt¦¨±Ð·|µLªk°¦¤â¾B¤Ñ¦Ó¤£¥i¦¬¬Bªº¦a¨B¡A¤]Åý¼Ú¬w¤H·U¨Ó·U²M·¡°ò·þ±Ð«H¥õ
©M¥j¥N¦´N¦s¦b©ó°ò·þ±Ð¦¨¥ß¤§«e¡@ªº²³¦h²§±Ð¤§¶¡¡A§è¤£²Mªº§ÛŧÃö«Yhttp://www.nbufront.org/html/Mas ... hristMythPart4.html
²Ä¤@³¡¡@
¡@Grant Allen»{¬°¦´Áªº¥Á±Ú¨Ì·Ó¯Ñ§@¦Ó¦b¨C¦~ªº¬K¤Ñ¤S¨£¨ì´Óª«µoªÞ,µø§@¬O¯«©úªº´_¥Íªº¤j¯à¡C»{¬°C¿q»P¤Ó¶§¯«ÀÀ¤H¤Æ¦³Ãöªº¾Ç¬£»{«ü¥X®J¤ÎDenderah·µùتº³B¤k®y¤Æ¨ªº¦ã¦èµ·©êµÛ²üù´µ¯«ªº§Î¶H,¦Ó¥j®J¤Î,ªi´µ,¦L«×«h®Ú¾Ú¬K¤Ñªº¤Ñ¶H¦Ó§â¤Ó¶§¦æ¸gªºª÷¤û®y¤Î¤ûµø§@¯«¸t,¦Ó¨ä¥L¤Ó¶§¯«¦pªüªiù,¼Ú¦è¨½´µ,Baccus¤S»P°²¯«C¿q¤@¼Ë³£¬O¦b12¤ë25¤é¼y¯¬¨ä½Ï¥Í¡C¦´Áªº²ÎªvªÌ³Qµø§@¬O¯«¤Æ¨¦¨¤Hªº¥Nªí,°ê¤ýY¦Ñ®z·|±a¨Ó³¡±Úªº¤£¶¶,´Nn³QÄ묹,¥t¥ß¦~»´ªº·s¤ý,«á¨Ó«h¥H¸o¥ÇªºÄ묹¥N´À°ê¤ýªºÄ묹,³QÄ묹ªº¸o¥Ç³Q°v¤W¤Q¬[¸g¹L3¤Ñªº·s/¤ë«Gªº¥æ´À¦Ó´_¬¡¦¨¸t,¤ë«G»P¦´Á¥Á±ÚªºÂצ¬¦³Ãö,¬ã¨s¥j¤Ú¤ñÛªº{°Ç©³(¥ì©Ô§J«n³¡)¾ú¥v®aBerosus«ü¥X¥j¥N¸Ó¦a¦³Ó¨C¦~¼y¯¬5¤Ñªº¼y¨å,¥D¹²¤¬´«,¹²¤Hµo¸¹¬I¥O¦Ó¥D¤H±q©R,³oÓ¦bSacaea¦a°Ïªº²ß«U¬OÅý³o¤¤Ñ³o¦ì¥sZoganesªº¼ÒÀÀ°²¤ý¼È²Îªv°ê®a,¤¤Ñ«á³Q»°¤U¤ý¦ì¦Ó¨üÃ@a,³Q¦Q¦º©Î°v¤W¤Q¦r¬[,®J¤Î¾Ç¾ÇªÌ«ü¥X,¨Ï®{¦æ¶ÇùØ¿ù¼g¦¨C¿q³Q±þ«á¡u¦Q¦º¡v¨ä¹ê§Æþ¦rªº¦Q¦º±`¬O«ü³Q°v¤W¤Q¬[(ª`¤C)/´¦µoC¿q®Ú¥»¤£¬O¥v¹ê¤Hª«ªºµÛ¦W¾ÇªÌJ.M.Robert-son¤ÎL.G.Ryland«ü¥X§Æþ¦rªºC¿q(Jesus)¹ïÀ³ªº§Æ§B¨Ó¤åJehoshua¬ù®Ñ¨È¬O¶®«Â±Ð¬£ªº²½¥q§â¤Ó¶§¯«¬ù®Ñ¨È¶S¬°¤Hªº¦W¦r(ª`¤K)¡@¡þC«°³Qù°¨x¸Ñ©ñ«e,¬ù®Ñ¨È¤Ó¶§¯«±Ð¬£¤´¯µ±K±R«HµÛ,¸Ñ©ñ«áªº¸Ó¬£«h¦]¤£¦A¦³«O«ù¯«¯µªº¥²n¦Ó¤½¶}¤F,ºÖµ®ÑùتºC¿q¨ü¼f,¨üÃø,°v¤W¤Q¬[,³Ì«á±ßÀ\³£¤£¬O¥v¹ê°O¿ý¦Ó¬O¯«¯µ¨Æ¥óªºÂà¿ý°O¸ü,
¡@¡@¤£ºÞC¿q¦¹¤H¦s¤£¦s¦b,©Î¦³¨S¦³¦º¦b¤Q¬[¤W,§í¬O¦b¤Q¬[¤Wªº¤£¬O¥L,¦@ÃÑ«o¬O,°ò·þ±Ðªº°_·½¬O²§±Ð«H¥õ,J.G.Frazer«ü¥X,ºÖµ®Ñ®Ú¥»¨S´£¨ìC¿qªº½Ï¥Í¤é¡C¦´Á±Ð®{¤]¤£´À°¸¹³¹L¥Í¤éªº,®J¤Î°ò·þ®{«h»{¬°°¸¹³¥Í¤é¬O1¤ë6¤é,3¥@¬ö¥½ªº¦è¤è±Ð·|¤è¨îq12¤ë25¤é¬O°¸¹³¸t½Ï¤é,¦ÓªF¤è±Ð·|¥ç¤]±Ä¥Î¦¹»¡(ª`11)/¥j¥N±Ô§Q¨È°ò·þ®{»¡[¯«¤÷§âC¿q½Ï¨°±q1¤ë6¤é§ï¦¨12¤ë25¤é¬O¦]¬°¸Ó¤é¬O¤Ó¶§¯«¥Í¤é, ³\¦h°ò·þ®{¤]°Ñ¥[¥LÌÂIÀë¼y¯¬ªº¬¡°Ê,C¿q½Ï¨°À³¤©²øÄY¤Æ,©ó¬O¯«¤÷̦@ij¸Ó¤é¬OC¿q½Ï¨°¦Óì¨Óªº1¤ë6¤é«h¦¨¤F¥DÅã¸`(Epiphany)]¡@
¡@¡@´_¬¡¸`«h¬O°ò·þ®{§â^°êªº¬K¤Ñ¤k¯«Eostre(Ostara)§ïÀY´«±¦¨Easter(´_¬¡¸`)¬O¬K¤À«á²Ä¤@Óº¡¤ë®É¤À¼y¯¬,³Ì±ß«h¬O4¤ë25¤é¼y¯¬¡C¥j®J¤Î²üù´µ¯«±þ¦º¶ë¯S(Set)´cÀs«h¦¨¬°¸t³ìªv±OÀs,¨Ã©ó¨C¦~4¤ë23¼y¯¬¸t³ìªv¸`,Arthur WeigallÆ[¬d¨ì°ò·þ®{¤£ª¾¤£Ä±¤¤·dªº´N¬O¥j®J¤Î¼Ú¾ú¦è´µªº¬ö©À߬ɦڥÁªº§âÀ¸,G.Higgins«ü¥X±Ò¥@¿ý4:7¡u·à,¤û,¤H,ÆN¡v¹ïÀ³ªº´N¬O¥|©uªº·à¤l®y(®L),ª÷¤û®y(¬K),¤ÑÃÈ®y(¬î¤À)¤Î¤ô²~®y(¥V¦Ü),±Ò¥@¿ýùزĤ@Ó®³¤}ÃM¥Õ°¨ªºÃM¤h(±Ò6:2)¬Oª÷¬P,²Ä¤GÓÃM¬õ°¨®³¼C¤Mªº¾Ô¯«·íµM´N¬O¥j¥Nªº¨ü±R«ôªº¾Ô¯«¤õ¬P,²Ä¤TÓ¶ÂÃM¤h«h¬O¤g¬P,¤âùØ®³µÛ¤Ñ¥(±Ò6:5)Á¿ªº¬O¤Ó¶§¦æ¸g¤Ñ¥®y®ÉȤé©]§¡µ¥,²Ä¥|¦ì¦ÇÃM¤h«h¬O¤ô¬PªºÃC¦â,¥¦´x±±µÛ¦º¤`,¥j¥N¤Ú¤ñÛ¤Hªº¯«¼q¦³¤C¶¥,¶H¼x¤é¤ë¤Î¤Ó¦æ¬P,³o¥|ÃM¤hªºÃC¦â´N¬O¥j¤Ú¤ñÛ¥e¬P¾Çªº¶Çz
¡@¡@°ò·þ®{¥Î§Æþ¦r¥ÀChi,Rho·d¥X¨ÓªºX«¬¼Ð»x(Chi-Rho)®Ú¾Ú¥j®J¤Î¾ÇªÌF.Petrie«üºÙ¥¦´N¬O²üù´µ¯«ªº¼Ð»x,¦n´X¤d¦~«áªº°ò·þ®{¹°¥Î¤F,½Ðª`·N§Æþ¤Æ®É¥N¦b®J¤Î¨È¾ú¤s¤j«°´N¦³°g«H°ò·þ±Ðªº±Ð®{¦s¦b·í¦aªº¨Æ¹ê¡C¥t¤@Ó¥Nªí°ò·þªº§Æþ¦r¥À¦êIHS쥻¬O§Æþ°s¯«Dionysus(Baccus)¼Ð»x,Âন©Ô¤B¤å«h¬OIES,©Ô¤B¤å¶§©Ê¦Wµüµ²§Àºóµü¬°us,©Ò¥H¦¨¤F©Ô¤B¤åªºIesus°²¯«C¿q,»P©Ô¤B¤åI¹ïÀ³ªº^¤åµÂনJ,©ó¬O§ÚÌ»s³y¤F¥v¸ñ¸ÌÃÒ¾ÚÁ¡®zªº¤d¥j¦t©z¤j±Ï¥D,°²¯«C¿qªº^¤åJesus,³y´N¤F³oÓ
³Ì¤£³ô¤J¦ÕªºÅ]°¦W¦r
¡@¡@ªø¦³¤s¦Ï¨¤ªº§Æþªª¯«Pan±a»â©z´µ¥h¤s³»,ºÖµ®Ñùتº°²¯«C¿q«h¦b¤s¤W³QÅ]°¤Þ»¤,¤¤¥j®É¥N«h§âÅ]°µe¦¨ªø¨¤ªº¤s¦Ï,¥j¤Ú¤ñÛªº¤s¦Ï¬OÅ]½~®y¶H¼x,¤Ó¶§¦¹«áº¥©¹°ª¦ì¨«,¬G¦Ó¤s¦Ï¯«³Qµø§@¶H¼x©Ê¦a±a»â¯«©ú©¹¤s³»¨«,¥j¤Ú¤ñÛ¥e¬P¾Çùتº¤Ó¶§¦]¬°¦æ¸g¥¨ÃÉ®y®É¹F³Ì°ªÂI¦Ó¥ÎÆj¤Î¤p¾s¶H¼x³o®É¤À,§Æþ¯«¸ÜªºÀ¹¶ø¥§·æ(Dionysus)³o¦ì±Ï¥@¥D«h¬OÃM¤G°¦Æj¦Ó«áÍ¢Åܦ¨¤Ñ¤W¬P®y,·s¬ùºÖµ¬G¨Æ®Ñùتº°¸¹³C¿q«hÃMÆj¤ÎÆj¾s(foal)¶iC«°,¹F¨ì¥L³Ì¥úºaªºÄA®p®É¨è