香港 Xocat Forum 討論區 » Culture 學術文化 » Philosophy & Religion 哲學宗教 » Religion makes life Happier?

34 ‹‹12

打印

Religion makes life Happier?

西南風

六三不是人

元老用戶組

Rank: 6 Rank: 6

帖子: 1059
積分: 13829
金錢: 2299
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2008-1-5

26^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-12 11:30 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

Ref:#18; #20; #21 and #1

#18
   一味靠嚇.
  當年已見過這帖子,有朋輩更視之為_重提"世界末日論".嘿!雄叔你反教!!!???

#20
   斷章取義.
  讓你再答一次.

"面對 4/6/89; 南亞大海嘯; 非洲的種族滅絕屠殺.............等等.
人們會因有信仰而開心和快樂嗎?"

"Back to the point, ARE YOU HAPPY?"

#1 & #21
   何苦來由?
   fatyin 168兄同 Paul +0803兄,這句話是三十几年前一個觀音寺(大嶼山羌山大澳道)的老和尚對一斑自  視為 '空虛' , '徬徨' 和 '不開心快樂'的年青人說的.

   何苦來由?
   願各位同知共監.

TOP

PAUL+0803

超高級用戶組

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

帖子: 62
積分: 1130
金錢: 128
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2005-9-13

27^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-12 18:26 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

引用:

原帖由 西南風 於 2008-1-12 03:30 發表
#18
   一味靠嚇.
  當年已見過這帖子,有朋輩更視之為_重提"世界末日論".嘿!雄叔你反教!!!???

#20
   斷章取義.
  讓你再答一次.

"面對 4/6/89; 南亞大海嘯; 非洲的種族滅絕 ...

My question is, can religion makes people more happy or less unhappy. It is a relative speaking. Life may be happy or unhappy, or sometimes happy and sometimes unhappy. Same as a pain curer medicine, if you have a headheache, you want to take a pain control medicine to lower your pain, it may not cure your real sickness, but at least give you some relief.

TOP

西南風

六三不是人

元老用戶組

Rank: 6 Rank: 6

帖子: 1059
積分: 13829
金錢: 2299
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2008-1-5

28^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-12 20:34 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

更正

是靈隱寺不是觀音寺,對不起.

TOP

西南風

六三不是人

元老用戶組

Rank: 6 Rank: 6

帖子: 1059
積分: 13829
金錢: 2299
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2008-1-5

29^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-13 12:05 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

引用:

原帖由 PAUL+0803 於 12/1/08 18:26 發表

My question is, can religion makes people more happy or less unhappy. It is a relative speaking. Life may be happy or unhappy, or sometimes happy and sometimes unhappy. Same as a pain curer med ...

唔會!

有信仰(有神論或無神論)只會令生活忙碌一點,充實一點點.

"信仰(有神論或無神論)"不是藥; 工具/手段; 捷徑....等等.

TOP

PAUL+0803

超高級用戶組

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

帖子: 62
積分: 1130
金錢: 128
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2005-9-13

30^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-13 22:13 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

引用:

原帖由 西南風 於 2008-1-13 04:05 發表

唔會!

有信仰(有神論或無神論)只會令生活忙碌一點,充實一點點.

"信仰(有神論或無神論)"不是藥; 工具/手段; 捷徑....等等.

Medicine works in many differnece ways.
It can be use as a curing media such as antibotic which either induce your body's immuse system or change yoour body environment to kill the bacteria or gems.
It can also be a media to suppress your body's reaction to make your fell more comfortible such as if you got a flu your doctor will give you medicine to suppress your running nose, headache etc. The medicine will not kill flu virus.

Difference sickness need different medicine. People with difference body condition would have difference effectiveness for same medicine. Try to find the medcine best for yourself either by your oner experience or advise from some reliable professionals.
More cautious, over dosage of medicine would be harmful.

Would religious be similar??

TOP

西南風

六三不是人

元老用戶組

Rank: 6 Rank: 6

帖子: 1059
積分: 13829
金錢: 2299
性別: 男
註冊時間: 2008-1-5

31^# 大中小發表於 2008-1-14 11:52 只看該作者

[隱藏廣告]

引用:

原帖由 PAUL+0803 於 13/1/08 22:13 發表

Medicine works in many differnece ways.
It can be use as a curing media such as antibotic which either induce your body's immuse system or change yoour body environment to kill the bacteria or g ...

我還是那句話:
"信仰(有神論或無神論)"不是藥; 工具/手段; 捷徑....等等.

另一方面,有論者認為:
"信仰(有神論或無神論)"是藥,是思想的麻醉藥***.Yes,你會開心一點.引用閣下的話:_
"More cautious, over dosage of medicine(drug) would be harmful(killed)."

藥***.(註)原論者用詞是"DRUG",譯者(不是我)用詞是"毒藥".作者和出處都忘了,很久之前的事了.