有冇人睇過佢既留德十年? 可以討論下

冇睇過.....

有看过

有看過牛棚

yes, have read this book.

好看嗎?

good good

我也只看過牛棚，文筆平實自然，直率而有感染力，感到知識分子在文革時真的做不了甚麼，一切都顛倒了，有無立場都可以被批，是一本值得推介的書。

不知道各位又如何評價留德十年？

引用:

原帖由 酒徒 於 2006-10-20 02:19 PM 發表
我也只看過牛棚，文筆平實自然，直率而有感染力，感到知識分子在文革時真的做不了甚麼，一切都顛倒了，有無立場都可以被批，是一本值得推介的書。

不知道各位又如何評價留德十年？

I actually do not think his book on the ten years of the Culturak Revoilution a particularly impressive book.  It is clear that during his time, he is too important to be attcked by the Red Guards.  While it is true that he suffered during the time, compared to a lot others in other filelds, he had relativeky better life during that time.