香港 Xocat Forum 討論區 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: asking for a friend [打印本頁]

作者: joshcox 時間: 2008-4-4 17:53 標題: asking for a friend

whilst on the topic, a friend of mine also looking to find a convertible, basically narrowed down to 3 choices

1. mazda MX5
2. bmw Z3
3. rover MGB

same criteria, how these 3 cars compare:-

how do the 2 cars compare in terms of:-

1. gas mileage
2. resale value
3. reliability
4. durability
5. insurance coverage (no NCB)

comments pls!

作者: 白蘭氏 時間: 2008-4-5 12:30

Go for a MT MX-5 la, you won't go wrong.
No problem on the maintaince and also the re-sale.

作者: jo630 時間: 2008-4-7 09:05

I will say BMW Z3. It may run more $. but the look and style. It is the best of all of it.I have 2002 , 3.0. James Bond color( light blue).

作者: joshcox 時間: 2008-4-7 12:28

thx guys... i will try to test drive all 3 in the coming weeks... will give some remakrs after test drive!

作者: Jeff9394 時間: 2008-4-7 13:28

引用:

原帖由 joshcox 於 2008-4-4 17:53 發表
whilst on the topic, a friend of mine also looking to find a convertible, basically narrowed down to 3 choices

1. mazda MX5
2. bmw Z3
3. rover MGB

same criteria, how these 3 cars compare:-
...

Driving in Hong Kong.
MX-5 (as specially the first generation)

Driving at somewhere like US, Aus, NZ....
Z3 2.8/3.0 MT(becoz Z3 is very heavy nearly same as E36 so 1.9 and 2.2 is bit powerless....)

Driver for styler try MGB (don't try the MGF)

[ 本帖最後由 Jeff9394 於 2008-4-7 13:31 編輯 ]

作者: kkwong7606 時間: 2008-4-8 12:24

引用:

原帖由 joshcox 於 2008-4-4 17:53 發表
whilst on the topic, a friend of mine also looking to find a convertible, basically narrowed down to 3 choices

1. mazda MX5
2. bmw Z3
3. rover MGB

same criteria, how these 3 cars compare:-
...

買D咁既類型車，跟本同理性無關，完全取決於個人喜好

作者: Jeff9394 時間: 2008-4-9 17:31

引用:

原帖由 kkwong7606 於 2008-4-8 12:24 發表
買D咁既類型車，跟本同理性無關，完全取決於個人喜好　

都唔係架我果時都係 Z3 2.8 at /M 手波同 NA6/8 手波同 MGF VVC 版
3 選一中諗左同睇左好耐架

歡迎光臨香港 Xocat Forum 討論區 (http://p.xocat.com/p/)